| On
23 May the All Party Parliamentary Group for Children (APPGC)
held a meeting on the topic “Children and young people who
display sexually harmful behaviour”. In 2002 the APPGC had
looked at the needs of young people displaying sexually harmful
behaviour, and the services available to help them. This meeting
in 2005 aimed to revisit the issue, looking at some evidence of
the extent of the problem, and hearing from both preventative
services and those providing treatment.
The
APPGC was privileged to hear from four experts:
Chris Atkinson, Policy Adviser, NSPCC
Tink Palmer, Director, Stop it Now!
Carole Easton, Chief Executive, ChildLine
Pam Hibbert, Principal Policy Officer, Barnardo’s
Chris
provided a brief update on what had happened since 2002; she concluded
by saying that there are two main areas where work is needed:
Where
children are required to register on the sex offender register,
if their case has gone through the criminal justice route rather
than the child protection route, so that treatment might not
be triggered.
On the emergence of new technologies as a method of displaying
sexually harmful behaviour, for example by downloading pictures
from the internet.
Tink
spoke about the calls Stop it Now! receives which come from:
-
adults concerned about other adults’ behaviour,
- adults concerned about their own behaviour (the largest percentage
of calls), and
- parents, carers or anyone working with young people concerned
about a young person’s behaviour (only 5% of their calls).
Tink
spoke about a case study from 2001 where a 13-year-old boy had
downloaded images from the internet. There were no counter-indicators
that he would have been a cause for concern – he had good
relationships with his parents, peers and school. Tink spoke with
the police officer involved in the case about the evidence from
the boy’s computer. It appeared that he had started downloading
adult porn, then moved on to look at children his own age, and
then children as young as six months old. Part of the treatment
process was to undo this fantasy.
Carole
spoke about ChildLine’s callers on this issue which include
young people who had experienced sexual abuse, third party callers
calling about someone they knew experiencing sexual abuse or abusing
young people, and a small number of young people concerned about
their own sexually abusive behaviour. ChildLine have produced
a briefing paper on this issue , which provides statistics from
their calls but also short quotes about cases. For example:
An
11-year-old girl called because her 14-year-old brother had gone
into her room ‘again’ the night before, pinned her
down and had sex with her. She said she could not tell anyone
else, as her brother had threatened to do it more and ‘it
hurt’.
A
13-year-old boy spoke to a counsellor for 26 minutes. He said
he needed help. He had been abusing a girl he babysat. He was
putting his hands up her skirt and ‘playing between her
legs’. It had been going on for three weeks and he wanted
help to stop – he had also done this to another child. His
mum’s best friend did it to him, but he had never told anyone
about that, or about what he had done or was doing to others.
Pam
also provided two case studies illustrating the differences between
those children whose case is identified by welfare agencies and
those whose case goes through the criminal justice system. She
then concluded by giving four national recommendations:
Central
Government guidance on children and young people who abuse should
be reviewed in England and Wales to make it clearer. Joint guidance
should also be developed by the Home Office, Department for
Education and Skills and the Department of Health to take account
of the Children Act 2004.
Guidance on best practice based on research evidence should
be produced for those working with children and young people
who display sexually harmful behaviour.
A national strategy linked to the National Service Framework
should be developed to ensure services are developed that are
both comprehensive and ‘tiered’.
Research should be commissioned into the effectiveness of services,
taking into account the views of service users, their families
and carers.
Future
meetings
The Officers of the APPGC have decided the remit of the Group’s
work programme for the forthcoming year. The Group will, as usual,
hold meetings focused on legislation relevant to children, for
example on the Children and Adoption Bill, Education Bill etc..
The remainder of the Group’s focus will mainly be on the
implementation of Every Child Matters and the Children Act 2004.
This will include hearing from the new Children’s Commissioner
for England, Professor Al Aynsley-Green, the development of children’s
trusts, and progress on information sharing. The APPGC will also
hold three topic-based meetings, one on each of the following
subjects: children’s rights in practice, child health, and
youth justice.
Please
contact Alison Linsey, Clerk to the Group (email: alinsey@ncb.org.uk):
•
To be added to the email mailing list to receive minutes and
notices of meetings
• For copies of minutes from any of the meetings
• For a free copy of the Group’s report ‘Commitment
to Children’
• For any further information about the Group
|